Menu of Castaways Steak & Seafood in Port Jefferson, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Castaways Steak & Seafood, located in the heart of Port Jefferson, delivers a dining experience that truly honors the maritime charm of its setting. This restaurant artfully blends the best of surf and turf with a menu that appeals to both seafood lovers and steak enthusiasts. From the moment you step inside, the nautical decor sets a relaxed yet refined tone, inviting you to savor each dish in an atmosphere reminiscent of the nearby harbor.

The menu at Castaways is a well-curated balance of classic and inventive dishes. Starting with the appetizers, the Calamari stands out, served with a unique sweet chili sauce that adds a subtle kick without overpowering the tender seafood. The Oysters Rockefeller offer a rich and indulgent taste of the sea, with perfectly baked oysters topped with a flavorful blend of cheeses and spinach. Those seeking something creamy and comforting will find the Spinach Dip a delightful choice, balancing freshness and richness.

Salads are far from ordinary here. The Watermelon Burrata Salad offers a striking contrast of sweet and creamy, a refreshing starter or side that brings brightness to the palate. The Peach & Kale Salad with Steak demonstrates the kitchen’s flair for pairing unexpected flavors — juicy peaches, hearty kale, and tender steak slices harmonize beautifully, making it a memorable entree or accompaniment.

Among the heartier options, the Steak with Gorgonzola Cheese Potatoes & Creamed Spinach epitomizes comfort and sophistication. The steak is expertly cooked, retaining a rare center for those who cherish authentic carnivore experiences, while the gorgonzola potatoes add a creamy, tangy depth that complements the slight bitterness of the creamed spinach perfectly. This dish encapsulates the surf-and-turf spirit of Castaways with a satisfying, bold finish.

Seafood offerings shine particularly in the Lobster Cheddar Sandwich and Mussels. The sandwich layers generous lobster meat with sharp cheddar, resulting in a rich, indulgent bite that pairs amazingly with the crispy truffle fries recommended by many patrons. The mussels are fresh, tender, and bathed in a subtle broth that showcases the freshest catches.

Soup and salad selections like the Seafood Chowder and Lobster Bisque come recommended, with the bisque often lauded for its creamy, smooth texture and rich lobster flavor. The chowder, while loved by many, has received some mixed feedback, occasionally veering on sour, which suggests a variable preparation. Still, it remains a staple that seafood aficionados should try at least once.

The raw bar is an invitation to indulge, especially the Seafood Tasting platters for varied group sizes, which highlight the freshest shrimp, clams, and oysters from local waters. The Colossal Shrimp Cocktail is another must-try, perfectly chilled with a zesty, well-balanced sauce that complements without overwhelming.

Cocktail selections show creativity and seasonal inspiration, such as the Chocolate Truffle and The Pumpkin Press. While the drink menu offers intriguing choices, it's worth noting the need for clear allergen and spice level labeling, as some patrons have experienced surprises, especially with cocktails containing spicy elements like the Carolina Reaper pepper.

Service at Castaways tends to be warm and attentive, enhancing the overall experience. Patrons frequently mention the friendliness of staff, personalized attention, and a welcoming atmosphere indoors and out. Outdoor seating allows you to savor your meal while soaking in the coastal afternoon or evening air, making it an excellent spot for romantic dinners or casual gatherings alike.

Though slightly on the pricier side, menu portions and quality justify the expense, making Castaways a worthwhile visit for those seeking fresh, well-prepared seafood combined with expertly cooked steak in an elegant yet relaxed environment. Whether you’re drawn by the promise of a luxurious seafood chowder or the decadence of lobster paired with gorgonzola potatoes, Castaways Steak & Seafood crafts an experience that is both memorable and true to its seaside roots.